How I Help Parents Tell Whether Tutoring Is Actually Working

By the end of this post, you’ll know three simple checks that tell you — within a few weeks — whether your child’s tutoring is moving the needle or just filling an hour.

Why This Matters to You

Tutoring is having a moment. Stanford’s National Student Support Accelerator just released its third annual review of state tutoring policy, and it found that 24 states plus Washington, D.C. now pay for K-12 tutoring directly (reported here). Many states kept their programs going even after pandemic money ran out. That’s good news. It also means more Sioux Falls families are getting tutoring through school, paying for it privately, or both.

But tutoring only helps if it’s the right kind. When it works, you see it: fewer homework battles, better quiz scores, a kid who says “I get it now” without being asked. When it doesn’t, you lose months — and your child starts to believe they’re “just bad at math” or “not a reader.”

Knowing what to look for protects your time, your money, and your child’s confidence.

Why Most Parents Can’t Tell

The main reason: parents judge tutoring by how the session feels instead of what changes between sessions. A friendly tutor and a happy kid are great. They aren’t proof of progress.

Other reasons tutoring stalls:

  • There’s no clear goal — “help with math” isn’t a target.

  • Sessions are too far apart, with nothing in between.

  • The tutor only helps with tonight’s homework and never fills the gap underneath it.

  • Nobody talks to the parent, so you’re guessing.

  • The real problem is getting started and staying organized — not the content — and nobody spots it.

The good news: you don’t need to be a teacher to check. You just need to ask the right three questions.

A 3-Step Guide to Checking Whether Tutoring Is Working

Step 1: Name One Specific Target

Pick one skill you can see: “reads a grade-level passage and retells it,” or “solves two-step equations without help.” Write it down with the tutor. You can’t measure “better at math.” You can measure one skill.

Picture a 4th grader who “just needs reading help.” Narrow it down, and it turns out he can sound out every word — but loses the meaning by the end of a paragraph. Once that’s the target, everyone knows exactly what to watch.

Step 2: Look for Change Between Sessions

Every two weeks, ask: “What can my child do now, on their own, that they couldn’t before?”

Common mistake: counting worksheets finished or hours logged. Busy isn’t progress. Another mistake: waiting for report cards. By then, a quarter is gone. Ask for a quick update — a text or two sentences is enough.

Step 3: Watch the Homework Table

Notice what happens at home. Is your child starting work faster? Asking fewer “I don’t get it” questions? Arguing less?

This ties it all together. The target tells you what should change. The check-ins tell you if it’s changing. The homework table tells you whether it’s sticking in real life. The reward: a kid who walks into class ready — and a parent who can stop guessing.

Conclusion

Tutoring works when it has a target, shows progress between sessions, and shows up at home. Check these three things:

  1. Name one specific target.

  2. Look for change every two weeks.

  3. Watch the homework table.

Try the first step this week — write down one skill and share it with your child’s tutor or teacher.

P.S. Not sure your child’s current support is the right fit? Reach out here and we’ll look at it together — or sign up for tutoring at 605 Tutor.

Natalie Micheel, reading and math tutor in Sioux Falls

About Natalie Micheel

Teacher, Tutor & Certified Executive Function Coach, MBA

15+ years teaching & tutoringPrivate, public & homeschoolEF & parent coachingAuthor of MathKind Guides

Natalie has spent more than 15 years teaching and tutoring kids in private schools, public schools and homeschools, and helping their parents figure out how to support them at home. She knows what works for real kids at real kitchen tables.

Natalie is the author of MathKind Guides, a revolutionary approach to math anxiety that teaches kids the facts, the calm-down tools and the planning skills together, so they learn the math and finally believe they're math people.

Before teaching, she built systems at Sprint, Medtronic and ITT. Today she brings it all together: reading and math tutoring at 605Tutor and executive function coaching at BestEFC, teaching students the planning, focus and follow-through skills school assumes they already have.

"My commitment: to be as generous and helpful as I can, and to reach and equip as many students and parents as I can."

If this sounds like your child

Homework can feel doable again.

Book a free discovery call. Tell me where your child is stuck, and I'll tell you honestly whether tutoring is the right fit, or what I'd recommend instead. The door is open.

Connect With Natalie →

Have a quick question first? Ask Natalie

Previous
Previous

How I Help Kids Who Dread Math Start Wanting to Do It

Next
Next

2026 Sioux Falls Homeschool Expo